Abstract
This paper presents a comprehensive comparative analysis of various multi-carrier pulse width modulation (PWM) techniques in the context of a medium-voltage cascaded H-bridge (CHB) static synchronous compensator (STATCOM). The study evaluates four commonly used carrier-based PWM methods with respect to key performance metrics, including semiconductor losses (conduction and switching), capacitor voltage balancing capability, current harmonic distortion, and the dynamic performance of the decoupled dq current controllers. These PWM methods are phase disposition (PD), phase opposition disposition (POD), alternative phase opposition disposition (APOD) as level-shifted PWM (LS-PWM), and phase-shifted PWM (PS-PWM). A detailed simulation model of a three-phase 11-level CHB-STATCOM operating at 11 kV and ±3.8 MVAR is developed to systematically assess each modulation scheme across different carrier frequencies. The results reveal that while LS-PWM techniques (PD, POD, APOD) offer lower semiconductor losses, they suffer from poor natural capacitor voltage balancing and inadequate harmonic performance at lower frequencies. In contrast, PS-PWM provides superior capacitor voltage balancing and harmonic reduction, even without auxiliary control mechanisms, albeit at the cost of increased switching losses. Quantitative analysis using two performance metrics confirms that higher carrier frequencies negatively impact the dynamic response of the current controllers. The findings suggest that PS-PWM with moderate switching frequency (0.5-1.0 kHz) is the most practical choice when considering all performance criteria holistically. This study contributes to establishing a systematic PWM selection framework for CHB-STATCOM applications in medium-voltage power systems.